In this film, with dialogue by Marguerite Duras, Romy Schneider develops in a world she relishes: a story that could be a Greek tragedy, a literary text. In it, she plays the part of Julia Kreuz, a woman who admits to her husband that she gave up her child six years before. She gets it into her head to find him. Knocking on the door of the couple who adopted her little boy, Julie causes a scandal from which there will be no coming back. The reunion, the discord between the couple, then the heartbreak caused by the battle for the child, enable Romy Schneider to employ all her talents as a grieving mother and a tragic figure. Her German leading man, Hans Christian Blech, was a star at the time and featured in The Longest Day (1962). The film was significant in that it was the starting point of a deep friendship between Romy Schneider and Michel Piccoli. He would become her accomplice, her friend, her confidant and her partner in around a dozen films. He lends his stature and his warm, reassuring voice to the character of Werner Kreuz, the patient husband, who doesn’t doubt from the start that his wife is increasingly wracked with guilt. Filmed in black and white, the movie is pared down, almost in the spirit of the New Wave. The music comes courtesy of the talented composer, Antoine Duhamel, whose score features mournful trumpets resonating throughout the film […]. The lack of understanding between the couple is taken to the highest level by these two actors, performing in perfect harmony. We know how the mysterious alchemy between these two, who identified with each other and became like brother and sister, went on to delight filmmakers. Claude Sautet, to name one, picked up on it quickly. Schneider, tormented, preoccupied, her brow furrowed, opposite a phlegmatic Piccoli: and we can imagine how these scenarios of amorous conflict might have inspired Marguerite Duras.

Isabelle Giordano, Romy Schneider: Film par film, Gallimard, Paris 2017